728_header.jpg (23748 bytes)
Google  Web AuctionBytes  

Home
Subscribe
Blog
EcommerceBytes
Podcasts
Forums
Merchant Directory
AuctionBytes TV
ABU Back Issues

Sponsor

COOL TOOLS

Calendar
eBay Fee Calculator
Collectors' Links
eBay Promo History
Bookshelf
Fraud Resources
Auction Site Fees
Auction Management
Payment Services
Storefronts Chart
Sniping Chart
Email List Hosting
Consignment Services
Drop-Off Store Laws
Ecommerce Resources
Photo Tips
Marketing Inserts
Yellow Pages
Classifieds

AUCTIONBYTES

Our Writers
Write For Us
Partners
Press
Advertising
About Us
Link To Us

Auctionbytes-NewsFlash, Number 1180 - December 23, 2005 - ISSN 1539-5065      | Next Story

eBay Patent Wars: MercExchange Reaches Agreeement with Patent Office
By Company-Issued Press Release
AuctionBytes.com
December 23, 2005
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

(Great Falls, VA) December 23, 2005 - MercExchange LLC announced today it has reached an agreement with the US Patent and Trademark Office in the reexamination of U.S. Patent No 6,202,051 (the '051), the online auction patent, concerning the patentability of this important innovation. The USPTO has accepted MercExchange's clarifying amendments to the claims of the patent, and has agreed that these claims are a patentable innovation.

"We wish to thank the USPTO and its dedicated staff for their tireless effort in reviewing this complex legal matter," said Thomas G. Woolston, founder of MercExchange. "Our four years of bitter litigation with eBay (NASDAQ: EBAY) has created an extremely large record, one that would be a challenge for any government agency to sort through. The USPTO and its examiner corps have done an admirable job."

In 2003, a jury in the District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia found eBay to be willfully infringing two of MercExchange's patents, awarding $35 million in damages, but the Court declined to issue a permanent injunction against eBay. The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed that decision, finding that the District Court should have issued the permanent injunction, and reduced the MercExchange award to $25 million in damages through March 2003. In addition, the Court of Appeals ordered the District Court to conduct a trial on the '051, which had been eliminated from the initial jury trial by a summary order of the District Court.

In July 2005, eBay filed a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review the Federal Circuit's reversal of the District Court's decision to not issue a permanent injunction. While on appeal of it's loss at trial, in March 2004 eBay also launched an unprecedented attack at the USPTO on the three patents in the District Court suit under the reexamination statutes.

"Today's agreement is an important milestone in our battle to defend our rights as a patent holder," Woolston said. We anticipate a successful resolution with the USPTO of the remaining patents under reexamination."

"eBay was found to be a willful infringer of our patents over two and one-half years ago, and we are now proceeding to the conclusion of their final appeal at the Supreme Court on the issue of the injunction. We look forward to returning to District Court to obtain our relief in this matter, and to finally competing with eBay by practicing our inventions free of infringement," Woolston said.

About MercExchange

MercExchange LLC, was founded in 1995 to improve businesses through the application of new digital technologies, especially in networked environments. MercExchange has been awarded several key patents involving the conduct of internet-based auctions and markets. The inventions and supporting intellectual property cover a range of applications; for additional information visit www.MercExchange.com.


Email this story to a friend.

| Next Story

Related Stories
  • AutoTrader Licenses Online Auction Patents from MercExchange - January 20, 2003, Issue #466
  • Judge Rules on Post-Trial Motions in eBay Patent Lawsuit - August 07, 2003, Issue #587
  • eBay Petitions USPTO to Reexamine MercExchange Patents - June 17, 2004, Issue #784
  • The eBay Patent Wars: Interview with MercExchange CEO Thomas Woolston - September 30, 2004, Issue #859
  • eBay Questions Jury Instructions During Patent Appeal Hearing - October 06, 2004, Issue #863
  • Court Rules on MercExchange v eBay Patent Case - March 16, 2005, Issue #975
  • USPTO Issues Action in eBay-Requested Re-Exam of MercExchange Patent - March 29, 2005, Issue #984
  • Bickering Continues in eBay Patent Case - March 30, 2005, Issue #985
  • eBay Asks Supreme Court to Hear Patent Case - May 13, 2005, Issue #1017
  • New Developments in eBay - MercExchange Patent Suit - September 28, 2005, Issue #1117
  • Lawrence Lessig Part of Amicus Brief in eBay Supreme Court Case - October 07, 2005, Issue #1124
  • The eBay Patent Wars: PESA Summit Skirmish - October 29, 2005, Issue #1140
  • The eBay Patent Wars: PESA Summit Skirmish - October 29, 2005, Issue #1139
  • Supreme Court to Hear eBay Patent Case over Injunction Ruling - November 28, 2005, Issue #1160
  • MercExchange Gets Funding before Facing eBay and Supreme Court - December 02, 2005, Issue #1164
  • eBay Patent Wars: Behind-the-Scenes Battles - December 21, 2005, Issue #1178
  • The eBay Patent Wars: U.S. Government Weighs In - March 10, 2006, Issue #1234
  • eBay Patent War: Best Case/Worst Case Scenarios - March 29, 2006, Issue #1247
  • eBay and MercExchange Have their Day in Court - March 29, 2006, Issue #1247
  • Supreme Court: No Injunction in eBay Case, Back to District Court - May 15, 2006, Issue #1279
  • eBay Patent Wars: Hearing Set for Friday - November 14, 2006, Issue #6
  • eBay Patent Wars: Judge Wonders about Design Workaround - December 29, 2006, Issue #1441
  • eBay Patent Hearing Set for June: Buy It Now at Issue - April 18, 2007, Issue #1519
  • eBay Patent Wars: MercExchange Likely to Appeal Injunction Ruling - July 30, 2007, Issue #1588
  • eBay Must Fork over Damages in MercExchange Patent Case - December 12, 2007, Issue #1683
  • eBay Formulating Appeals Strategy in MercExchange Patent Case - December 13, 2007, Issue #1684
  • eBay v MercExchange Patent War: It's Over - February 28, 2008, Issue #1737



  • Discuss this story in our forums.

    Ecommerce Podcasts

    Site Index
    Copyright 1999-2008. Steiner Associates LLC. All rights reserved