728_header.jpg (23748 bytes)
Google  Web AuctionBytes  

Home
Subscribe
Blog
Podcasts
Forums
AuctionBytes TV
ABU Back Issues

Sponsor

COOL TOOLS

Calendar
eBay Fee Calculator
Collectors' Links
eBay Promo History
Bookshelf
Fraud Resources
Auction Site Fees
Auction Management
Payment Services
Storefronts Chart
Sniping Chart
Email List Hosting
Consignment Services
Drop-Off Store Laws
Ecommerce Resources
Photo Tips
Marketing Inserts
Yellow Pages
Classifieds

AUCTIONBYTES

Our Writers
Write For Us
Partners
Press
Advertising
About Us
Link To Us

Go to Current Issue

Auctionbytes-Update, Number 15 - June 03, 2000 - ISSN 1528-6703     Previous Story | Contents | Next Story


Commission - Impossible? Brokering Items for Profit
By David Steiner
AuctionBytes.com

June 04, 2000
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

If you've been selling online for any length of time, you've undoubtedly had a friend, family member or colleague say, "Hey, I have this (fill in the blank) that might be valuable. How about selling it for me on eBay?"

This immediately causes the little man in my head to whip out his calculator and lecture me, "Let's see, this is going to cost me a $2 listing fee and an eBay commission. Then I have to go and get the item, take a picture of it, make sure it works properly, describe it, post the auction, communicate with a buyer, pack and ship it...all for the 5-10% commission my friend thinks is appropriate?" Hmmm...

Usually, I put the brakes on the conversation right there. I patiently explain that I don't really broker items, but that I would be glad to help them navigate the online auction site of their choice so that they can sell the item themselves.

OK, call this avoidance. Also, the little man in my head doesn't like to be bothered a lot.

However, if you're a little more motivated than the two of us, and you've learned to sell successfully on any of the multitude of online auction services, then you have developed a marketable skill...a skill that can make you money by offering this service to others. It seems pretty straightforward, but along with brokering items for people comes a whole new set of logistical problems.

Factor #1: Setting a price for the brokered item
It's not as simple as selling your own item. You now have to make sure your client is satisfied with the selling price.

According to LizArtz99@aol.com, who sells over 90% of her items for other people, "The main and foremost difficulty is that the client always assumes their items will bring the kind of price they think it will, and it's normally a much higher amount than is realistic. It's hard to make people understand that their items are not going to bring them new wealth."

Ljoh774019@aol.com has a minimum selling price of $19.95 for her brokered items and says, "Be comfortable communicating with the person you are listing for. Be upfront with expectations of what the item will bring at auction."

A good idea is to do a completed auction search of the item and let clients see what they might expect to get for theirs. Explain that there are a lot of variables when it comes to getting a top price. Picture quality, timing (some items sell better at different times of the year) and competition (you may list your item and find that 5 others go up at the same time) are a few.

Factor #2: Listing the item
Most sellers I spoke with were insistent on having the item on premises so that they could inspect it themselves. Never take someone's word about the item's condition. Once you're satisfied with the condition of the item, research it carefully and write the auction description. It's a good idea to send the description to the client to look it over before you actually post the auction. They may be able to add some good information. But remember, they asked for your auction expertise, so if they balk at something in your description, explain why you did it, but don't change it if you feel strongly about it.

Factor #3: Communicating with the Buyer after the Auction Ends
This is tricky if you don't have the item at your site. Otherwise, you handle it like any other auction. If the item is still at your client's home or business, and they are shipping it, then you have to coordinate between the buyer and your client. Take pains to ensure that payment is made in a timely manner, and that shipping is expedited as well. You're not really an advocate for either party. Consider yourself like an air traffic controller, trying to safely land two planes simultaneously. You are trying to mediate the best possible transaction for everyone involved.

Factor #4: How do I handle refunds?
You know them, you hate them, but you handle them the same way you would for your own auctions. Make sure your client is aware up front that there's a possibility that a buyer might return an item.

"If the person I am dealing with refuses to offer a refund then I will not sell for them," says Judy F., who at various times lists about 50% of her auctions for other people. "This is where it gets a bit risky, as it is YOUR feedback that can be affected."

Also be prepared to pay for your own mistakes. If items get broken or lost while in your possession, it's your responsibility to reimburse the client.

Factor #5: How much commission do I charge for handling the sale?
The sellers who I spoke to charged clients between 10% and 35% for their services. Judy F. has her formula all worked out. "Depending on who I am selling for I charge between 25-30%. Also, I expect the listing fees right at the start and the selling fees right at the end. These fees are NOT included in my commission as I am charged these fees right at the start and end of the transaction."

LizArtz99@aol.com charges a flat third plus listing and final value fees, but other sellers find 10% satisfactory and some even use the barter system with their clients. Whether it's 10% or 35%, make it worth your while. You are taking responsibility for the entire transaction and your time is valuable. It's also YOUR feedback that's on the line. If you feel that you're not being paid enough, you won't put your best effort forward, and you will be shortchanging your client.

These are just a few of the things to be aware of if you're selling for other people. One last tip - if you don't know your client well, consider using a private auction, where names of the bidders are not made public. This can avoid a rather nasty situation where the client may try to circumvent you in the deal. According to Nancy, seller 007 on eBay, "I have had consignees skate the deal right under me by contacting the high bid through another source after the auction was over."

The benefit of brokering is that you'll probably never lack items to put up for auction again! In fact, you probably won't be able to keep up! The drawback is that you've made the already involved auction process even more complicated by adding another person to the mix.

One common piece of advice from all of the sellers was to set the terms of your agreement with the client UP FRONT. Get it in writing, if necessary - commission structure, refund policy, etc. - all the points that your client should understand before going forward.

Says LizArts99@aol.com, "Even if you're the best of friends. Make sure you cover all the bases. That way, there will never be any misunderstandings. Otherwise, it won't be worth your time, and you are the one doing all the work."

I can hear the little man in my head taking out his calculator again.

About the author:

David Steiner is President of Steiner Associates LLC, publisher of AuctionBytes.com. David was formerly a television producer.



Email this story to a friend.

Previous Story | Contents | Next Story

Related Stories
  • Getting the Most out of an Estate - December 18, 1999, Issue #4
  • Second Hand Rose - July 15, 2000, Issue #18
  • Online Auction Consignment for 'Offline' Owners - October 21, 2000, Issue #24
  • myEZsale Consignment Service - November 04, 2000, Issue #25
  • Letter from Reader - December 02, 2000, Issue #27
  • Avid Collector Turns Into 'Mystery Seller' - May 19, 2001, Issue #38
  • Mining Inventory - June 30, 2001, Issue #41
  • eBay Creates Directory of Brokers - February 15, 2002, Issue #259
  • Online Auction Management Tools: Help with Consignment Sales - November 17, 2002, Issue #83




  • Discuss this story in our forums.

    Ecommerce Podcasts

    Site Index
    Copyright 1999-2008. Steiner Associates LLC. All rights reserved