Subscribe    RSS Feeds    Twitter            Contact Us 
Web Site  
728_header.jpg (23748 bytes)
 Home   EB Blog   AB Blog   Letters   Podcasts   ABTV   Forums   EPIS   PR Service   Classifieds   Ecommerce EKG   Service Ratings   
Service Ratings 
   Auction Sites
   FP Marketplaces
   Inventory Management
   Payment Services
   Storefronts & Carts
   Sniping Services
   Wholesale/Dropshipping
   Email List Hosting
   Consignment Services
   Ecommerce EKG 
   Auction Calendar
   Collectors' Links
   eBay Promo History
   Bookshelf
   Fraud Resources
   Drop-Off Store Laws
   ABTV
   Ecommerce Resources
   Photo Tips
   Marketing Inserts
   Yellow Pages
   Advertising

EcommerceBytes-NewsFlash, Number 547 - May 30, 2003 - ISSN 1539-5065     | Next
eBay-Contested MercExchange Patents Are on the Block
By Ina Steiner
EcommerceBytes.com
May 30, 2003




Emerging victorious after years of battling eBay in a patent infringement lawsuit, Thomas Woolston, President of MercExchange, said he's ready to move on. A jury reached a verdict on Tuesday, declaring eBay had willfully infringed MercExchange's consignment fixed-price and software search agent patents and handed MercExchange $35 million in damages.

When asked if he would go after small niche sites in the auction industry, Woolston said, "it is not our goal to enforce these patents, we want to sell off our Intellectual Property rights." MercExchange is talking to companies "the size and scope of eBay," who are very interested in purchasing his patent portfolio. "We've had good discussions with these companies," Woolston said.

Would Woolston sell his patents to eBay now? Woolston said eBay has not spoken to him outside a courtroom since June 2000 when he first approached them about purchasing his patents. "I always thought the eBay community was the natural home for the patents," he said.

However, if eBay wants to purchase exclusive rights to the patents, there may be antitrust concerns.

"Acquisitions of patents can create the same antitrust issues if they give market power to the acquiring company," according to Kevin Buford, partner and leader in the mid-Atlantic Intellectual Practice area at Holland & Knight LLP.

Yet it may be in eBay's interest to make such a purchase: MercExchange intends to file a motion to have the court enter an injunction against eBay and Half.com, according to Jennifer Albert, a partner and the co-head of the Intellectual Property Practice at Hunton & Williams LLP, which represented MercExchange. This would affect the fixed-price listings on the eBay and Half sites.

In order for a judge to deny an injunction, there must be a "sound reason," such as an overriding public interest, according to Holland & Knight's Buford. "I am unaware of any facts that would suggest eBay has a sufficient "sound reason" to rely on in this case."

eBay could try to reach a provisional settlement with MercExchange while the appeals process goes on, but Buford said MercExchange would be unlikely to agree to this since they have procedural advantage.

eBay said the court has established a two or three week time frame for the filing of post trial motions. "Ours will consist of motions to overturn the verdict, vacate the decision and dispute the damages," said eBay spokesperson Kevin Pursglove.

Hunton & Williams said it expects the judge to make his ruling on damages about 30 days after post-trial briefs, which are due in about two weeks.

In the meantime, the patents may be sold to the highest bidder.

You may quote up to 50 words of any article on the condition that you attribute the article to EcommerceBytes.com and either link to the original article or to www.EcommerceBytes.com.
All other use is prohibited.

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for our Email Newsletters

Email this story to a friend.

| Next

 EcommerceBytes Blog 
 AuctionBytes Blog 
 Letters to the Editor 
Related Stories 
Related Stories
  • eBay Challenges Company over Domain Name - February 28, 2001, Issue #30
  • Bidder's Edge and eBay Settle Lawsuit - March 01, 2001, Issue #31
  • PayPal Shareholders File Class Action Lawsuit Against PayPal & eBay - July 12, 2002, Issue #357
  • User Sues eBay over Feedback System - January 24, 2003, Issue #469
  • Jury Rules Against eBay in Patent Lawsuit - May 28, 2003, Issue #545
  • eBay-Contested MercExchange Patents Are on the Block - May 30, 2003, Issue #547
  • Another Patent Lawsuit Around the Corner for eBay? - July 11, 2003, Issue #574
  • eBay to Appeal Jury Verdict in Patent Trial - August 12, 2003, Issue #589
  • Bidz.com Inc. Sues eBay for Trademark Infringement - October 20, 2003, Issue #631
  • eBay Settles Patent Lawsuit filed by Tumbleweed against eBay and PayPal - January 06, 2004, Issue #675
  • Tiffany Sues eBay over Fakes - June 22, 2004, Issue #787
  • Users Sue eBay over Billing Glitches - July 06, 2004, Issue #798
  • Appeals Court Rules in eBay Feedback Liability Lawsuit - July 26, 2004, Issue #813
  • eBay Sellers Charged With Trademark Infringement - August 23, 2004, Issue #833
  • PayPal Upgrade Causes Major Outage, Affects Debit-Card Users - October 12, 2004, Issue #867
  • Bidders File Lawsuit Accusing eBay of Shill Bidding - February 24, 2005, Issue #961
  • Butterfields Employees File Class Action Lawsuit against eBay - March 04, 2005, Issue #967
  • eBay Charged with Racketeering in Class Action Lawsuit - April 07, 2005, Issue #991
  • Tentative Settlement Reached in eBay Stock 'Spinning' Lawsuit - April 29, 2005, Issue #1007
  • Appeal Filed in eBay Discrimination Lawsuit - July 22, 2010, Issue #2331


  •  

    About Us      Privacy Policy      Link to Us      Partners      Our Writers      Write for Us      Press        Site Index

    Copyright 1999-. Steiner Associates LLC. All rights reserved.